The Delaware Supreme Court started the New Year with a resolution of sorts for lawyers. In a decision issued on January 2, 2013, the Court instructed that, if counsel agrees to alter a deadline in the trial court’s scheduling order, all remaining deadlines will be rendered inapplicable:
Henceforth, parties who ignore or extend scheduling deadlines without promptly consulting the trial court will do so at their own risk. In other words, any party that grants an informal extension to opposing counsel will be precluded from seeking relief from the court with respect to any deadlines in the scheduling order.
The Court also stressed the priority of avoiding any changes that would affect the trial date:
. . . [I]f the trial court is asked to extend any deadlines in the scheduling order, the extension should not alter the trial date. Counsel may face a compressed time period to complete discovery, or the filing of dispositive motions, but the most important aspect of the scheduling order–the trial date–will be preserved.
And, the Court warned, where the trial court does elect to postpone the trial date, the parties should expect that their new date will be after “all other trials already scheduled on the court’s docket.” In other words, there’s no butting in line.
The Court’s admonition is a welcome one. All too often, counsel wants to extend a deadline that truly should not be extended. There seems to be a belief by some practitioners that all requests or extension must be granted. This simply is not true. In fact, a lawyer may not agree to extend a deadline that would detrimentally affect his client’s case.
Moreover, the parties negotiate the scheduling order–it is not a set of arbitrary deadlines forced upon them by the court. It is a set of obligations created entirely by agreement. Thus, I tend to have a fairly low tolerance for the opposing counsel who cries that he just couldn’t meet the deadlines and whines that I’m such a monster for not agreeing to extend them. In my book, a deal’s a deal and there’s a lot to be said for keeping your promises.