3d Circuit Will Rule on Student Discipline Based on MySpace Posting

Facebook postings are powerful things.  We’ve seen them get their authors fired from their jobs, be used in legal proceedings, and, recently, land judges in hot water. The Third Circuit Court of Appeals, which is the federal appellate court for Delaware, Pennsylvania, New Jersey, and the Virgin Islands, is set to rule in a different type of social-networking legal matter.  The plaintiff in the case is a middle-school student in the Blue Mountain School district in Schuykill County, Pennsylvania.  She was suspended when she created a fake MySpace profile for her principal, using a fake name but his real photograph, claiming that he was a pedophile and sex addict.  The profile was riddled with sexual vulgarities. The student created the profile at home after school. myspace

At issue in the case is whether, and to what extent, the school can discipline students for out-of-school conduct that disrupts or otherwise affects the school and educational process. Federal appellate court judge, D. Michael Fisher, cautioned the school district about the possible impact the case could have if the court were to rule in its favor, saying, “Do we want our school districts to become Internet police?”

The question of how far a school can and should go outside the boundaries of the school yard is paralleled by the debate about employers’ monitoring of employees’ off-duty conduct.  How far is too far?  And, once you start, do you have a duty to continue to keep tabs of students’ or employees’ online affairs?  It’s a question that is far from settled but front and center in this rapidly developing area of the law.

Recent related posts:

Job applicants required to submit Facebook passwords for background checks

More Stories from the Facebook Frontier

Ethical Implications of “Friend-ing” a Witness on Facebook

MySpace Post Results in Termination of Nursing Student

One thought on “3d Circuit Will Rule on Student Discipline Based on MySpace Posting

  1. It amazes me how serious the internet has become. What if the student had just drawn a picture of the principal instead of creating a fake profile. Would it have made the news?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s